IT’S A TRICK – THIS ISN’T REALLY ABOUT PUNK ROCK
Admittedly, there is little that is punk rock in Workoff, A. In my Venn Diagram of musical taste, the two big circles are labeled thus: a) denim and sunglasses b) earnest wuss rock. It is so-so fair to add cultural implications to these differences of personal expression in music (smoky rooms and crying in your bedroom respectively), and cast the denim sunglasses bands in ye olde EN-GER-LAND, and the collection of wusses in the States. Your given e.g.’s lie in Franz Ferdinand, Manchester in the 90’s, and the Cribs from the UK and on the other end, Ben Gibbard, Elliot Smith, and say any of the pop punk penchant bands, like the Weakerthans. There are line straddlers of course, with B.R.M.C and the Dandies hanging onto the sunglasses end of the American side, and Belle and Sebastian covering the trans-Atlantic wuss-rock connection. HOWEVER, that is my personal range of expressed emotion – from confidence in clever asides, again, sunglasses, optimism in spite of detachment, to overt sensitivity, in general earnest-ness, and goddamnit, optimism in spite of being burned. Ah ha – I believe this is the range that cynicism encompasses, but that’s a bigger conversation.
What this doesn’t cover however, is punk rock, which I seem to have been talking about a lot of the past few months. I don’t think it’s fair to include punk rock as a part of my musical range, because I’m not gung-ho enough to commit completely. It’s a big fucking commitment, to one ideal or another, and you’ve got to apply a pretty hard line to take that shit seriously. Right, so you start out as a reaction to a culture that isn’t about anything you want to be a part of, exactly what a counter culture is supposed to do, and then you start taking yourselves too seriously, and before you know it you used to be a sort of androgynous dude or chick who used to play really fast, or was a 50’s kitsch revival, and you used to say and sing funny things. BUT THEN you fucking wake up and you’ve got no neck and you’re punching kids in the pit, or you wake up and you think that anarchy is a legitimate possibility, or you wake up and worst of all you lost your sense of humor years ago and self-seriousness overwhelms everything you do (and you’re married to Thurston Moore, what?). When did punk stop being funny?
Then you realize the punk rock that my generation is trying to do is working really hard on missing the point. Worse yet, we need punk rock right now, because most of music is working really hard on being obvious and boring. Right now, music is worse than pulling retro threads from music we’ve heard before and sounding like other things (the Beatles) – it is working full-on to imitate it, for nostalgia’s sake. This is why we have bands like Beirut and the Fleet Foxes, both of whom I like, but find to be incredibly hollow in a lot of ways. I get the impression that they’re saying what’s been said in either bohemian France or early 20th century, respectively. It ain’t gonna be enough to be music historians, and obviously a chunk of written criticism on my end ain’t going to help either, unless it makes musicians mad enough to starting writing music again, not classing myself as completely a critic yet, because I think I’ve got something creative and constructive to send out at some point (aside from run-on sentences) BUT FOR NOW, EGGING ON, because as much as musicians hate critics, and shouldn’t listen to them, hating critics is going to make you better at writing music, because that’s what you do.
I’ve got some things about bands I like that are working on pop culture deconstruction, but I think going in that direction takes away from making musicians mad. Work harder, maybe I’ll help out at some point. In general, I think everyone should be working harder (me too!) or else we’ll continue to think it’s really important when Led Zepplin reunites again. Or we’ll continue to be people who think it’s really important to remember the day that the guy who shilled Oxi-clean died. And no one wants that.
And oh yeah, the Pixies never stopped being funny, David Johansen never stopped wearing lady clothing, and if Joe Strummer were still around, I imagine he would still maintain a fine sense of humor, decency, and integrity, and would definitely wear a fucking righteous pair of sunglasses.





